Chironomia refers to gestures of the hand, but in fact
is broader than hand gestures. Chironomia extended to
idea of rhetoric muette or rhetoric tacens by generalizing
gestures to become what we now refer to as pantomime.
Feuillet notation becomes a notation to describe silent,
non-textual gestures. Ballet dancing, augmented by pantomime,
becomes a very powerful way to extend gestures into a language.
Genaro Magri, Gasparo Angiolini, John Weaver and Jean-Georges
Noverre faced a great deal of opposition, but their ideas of
using the expressive but silent gestures of chironomia or
pantomime in dance prevailed.
The basis of chironomia is that human expressions of
emotions is universal. The death of a loved one is
accompanied by sadness, no matter what society; these
emotions are universal. There are gestures which may
then be used to signify these emotions, and these
gestures may be used as a language. It is possible
(likely) that these gestures are society-specific, but
that is relatively minor. (The chironomia can vary from
one society to the next, but such a chironomic language
of gestures can be constructed.) To get an idea of the
chironomia used in western Europe circa the Baroque, a
short description will be given. However, there is a
bigger problem to be settled.
Feuillet notation (as an example) was extended as a language
or notation to codify the eloquence muette found in dance.
Thus Feuillet notation deals with silent gestures found in
ballet: toe, ankle, knee, leg, torso, finger, hand, wrist,
elbow, arm, head, even chapeau movement. However, chironomia
(pantomime) also extends emotional expression, dealing with
the silent expression of emotions associated with hand, arm,
foot, etc. Thus ambiguity exists (that is the way of life)!
Thus, in dance, chironomia must be used to extend the motion
of the body that does not conflict with dance steps, motion
of the arms in dance, etc. A choice presents itself to the
dancer: emphasize dance (steps) or emphasize emotional
pantomime. Sometimes dance takes precedence, sometimes the
pantomime of emotions takes precedence. The artist makes
this choice, the audience decides if the artist was the master.
Magri was well aware that "eloquence" in dance does NOT necessarily
mean beauty; rather, inelegant dance might emphasize the humor
found in burlesque dance. This line of reasoning is very similar
to the attacks made later on the great pictoral artist, Thomas
Eakins. Must art be about beauty? Whose concept of beauty? Can
the art that one person finds beautiful, be art, but not beautiful
from someone else's viewpoint? Is art only beautiful if it focuses
upon the wealthy or powerful, or can art be beautiful if it focuses
upon poor, hard working people? What is "beautiful" cannot be
decided by any one class (even if a Plato or an Aristotle dissents).
An abbreviated description of chironomia will be provided.
We all should have been exposed to chironomia in the forms
found in silent films of the early twentieth century, or the
master of pantomime, Marcel Marceau. However, we seek an idea
of the theoretical basis of the system of chironomia. Our
source is "A Pratical Treatise on Gesture: Chiefly Abstracted
From Austin's Cironomia. Adapted To The Use Of Students, And
Arranged According To The Method Of Instruction In Harvard
University", by Jonathan Barber.
Feet and Lower Limbs
A series of figures are provided to explain foot and leg positions
First Position of Right Foot, R1 (Fig. 1): moderate
Second Position of Right Foot, R2 (Fig. 2): moderate
First Position of Left Foot, L1 (Fig. 3): moderate
Second Position of Left Foot, L2 (Fig. 4): moderate
Extended Right Foot (Fig. 5): retiring in alarm
Extended Right Foot (Fig. 6): advancing in boldness
See Plate I: Figure 1 through Figure 8.
notation:
"a" advances
"r" retreats
"tr" traverses
"c" crosses
"st" starts [theatrical, thus on stage]
"sp" stamps [theatrical, thus on stage]
advance, retire, traverse, cross (Fig. 7 and Fig. 8)
Foot Faults
"Fault 1" Weight
equally on both feet (change is inconvenient).
"Fault 2" Not turning
the toes outward.
"Fault 3" Feet too
close together (instability).
"Fault 4" Feet are
too far apart (swaggering air).
"Fault 5" Not advancing
or retreating properly (toes not turned outward,
steps at proper distance).
"Fault 6" Steps too
long or too short.
"Fault 7" Too frequent
a change of position (implies anxiety).
"Fault 8" Maintaining
the same position for too long a period of time.
"Fault 9" Not keeping
the leg of the gesture foot straight, and not
gently bending the other leg.
Head, Eyes, Shoulders, Trunk
Eye
Directions
Head
Positions
I
Inclined
F
Forwards
E
Erect
A
Averted
AS
Assenting
D
Downwards
DN
Denying
U
Upwards
TS
Tossing
R
Around
S
Aside
V
Vacuity
Eye and Head Faults
"Fault 1" Directing
the head and eyes away from the audience.
"Fault 2" Turning
the head too rapidly, or in a jerking motion.
"Fault 3" Any
excessive or unnatural action of the countenance.
"Fault 4" Elevating and
retracting the head too much (air of arrogance).
Trunk
"Fault 1" A constant
inclination of the body to one side, which
conveys a notion of distress.
Positions, Motions, and Elevation of the Arms
"Arm raised: facing the dancer" and
Arm rotated: looking vertically down on the dancer
See Figure 10 and Figure 11.
"Various arm motions defined within a shere"
See Figure 12.
Positions and Motions of the Hands and Arms
First Class of Positions
"n" signifies the natural
state of the fingers and hands.
"x" signifies the excited
state of the fingers and hands: fingers extended and
separated.
"c" signifies the clenched fist.
"i" signifies pointing with the
index finger (all other fingers contracted) to discriminate
or point out (for scorn).
"g" signifies grasping.
Second Class of Positions: palm
"p" signifies prone (palm
turned downwards).
"s" signifies supine (palm
turned fully upwards).
"n" signifies inwards (palm
turned towards the breast, thumb erect).
"o" signifies outwards (palm
turned from the body, thumb downward).
"v" signifies vertical (plane
of palm perpendicular to the horizon, fingers pointing upwards).
Third Class of Positions: both hands
together "B" signifies both hands
"ap" signifies applied (palms
pressed together, fingers and thumbs line up).
"cl" signifies clasped (when
fingers of one hand are inserted between fingers of the
other hand, one thumb overlapping the other).
"cr" signifies crossed (when
one hand is laid across the other on the breast).
"fl" signifies folded (when the
fingers of one hand at the second joint are all laid
between the thumb and forefinger of the other, the thumbs
crossing each other.)
"in" signifies inclosed (when
the back of one hand, slightly bent, is received in the
palm of the other, the thumbs crossing each other.)
"tc" signifies touching (when
the points of the thumb and fingers of each hand are
brought lightly into contact.)
"wr" signifies wringing (when
both hands are first clasped together and elevated,
then depressed and separated at the wrists without
disengaging the fingers.)
"en" signifies enumerating (when
the index finger of the right hand is laid successively
upon the index finger then the different fingers of the
left.)
Fourth Class of Positions: when the
hands touch other parts of the body: B (breast); E (eyes);
L (lips); F (forehead), C (chin); motions (direction and
manner of moving), force of motion
direction
"a" signifies ascending.
"d" signifies descending.
"r" signifies to the right.
"l" signifies to the left.
"f" signifies forwards.
"b" signifies backwards.
manner
"n" signifies noting
(when the hand is drawn back, raised, then advanced
and with a gentle stroke depressed.)
"p" signifies pushing
(when the arm is first retracted, then thrust
forward in the direction the hand points.)
"w" signifies waving
(when fingers point down, then with a quick motion
of elbow and wrist point up.)
"fl" signifies the flourish
(a circular movement over the head.)
"sw" signifies the sweep
(a curved movement from one shoulder, with increasing
velocity during which the hand switches from supine to
vertical [or vertical to supine].)
"bk" signifies beckoning
(when with forefinger or whole hand, palm turned inwards,
a motion is made towards the breast.)
"rp" signifies repressing
([opposite of beckoning]: when with forefinger or whole
hand, palm turned outwards, a motion is made away from
the breast.)
"ad" signifies advancing
(when the hand is moved downwards and backwards, then
moved forwards and raised to horizontal, while a step is
made in advance to aid action of arm and hand.)
"sp" signifies springing
(when the hand gesture is almost finished, using the
wrist quickly, the hand gesture suddenly flies upwards.)
"st" signifies striking
(when the forearm and hand descend rapidly with force.)
"rc" signifies recoiling
(when the after a gesture such as striking, the arm and
hand return back to their original position.)
"th" signifies throwing
(when the arm due to the gesture, is flung in the
direction of the addressing person.)
"cl" signifies clinching
(when the hand forms a fist, any arm position signifies
violence, threats, etc.)
"ll" signifies collecting
(when the arm from any extended position sweeps inward.)
"sh" signifies shaking
(when any unsteady motion is made by arm with hand.)
"pr" signifies pressing
(when the hand is forcibly pressed anywhere on the body
where the hand was previously placed.)
Faults to Avoid Concerning Arm and
Hand Gestures
Hand Faults
"Fault 1" hand placed edgewise
(not visible).
"Fault 2" palm hollowed
(not visible).
"Fault 3" flat hand (fingers
held together), or hand in supine position.
"Fault 4" little finger held
downward (looks affected).
"Fault 5" too frequent a use
of index finger: to be used only for discriminating
(pointing).
"Fault 6" moving fingers
(while talking, for example).
"Fault 7" a trembling hand, or
fingers pointing in strange directions is distracting.
"Fault 8" keeping fingers
separated.
"Fault 9" hand motions should
be coordinated to move with (other body movements and
music).
"Fault 10" following hand
movements with the eye (feedback to adjusting gestures).
Arm Faults
"Fault 1" Not extending the
arm with freedom, instead, the arm is confined near the
side and in doing so, is too angular at the elbow.
"Fault 2" Holding the arm in
too rigid a manner.
"Fault 3" Action of the arm is
confined to a single line, preventing no observable change
of gesture.
"Fault 4" Too frequent use of
horizontal arm swing. This gesture is to be used only
for denial or rejection.
"Fault 5" Gestures MUST terminate:
moving from gesture to gesture, it is not clear where these
gestures end and start a new gesture.
"Fault 6" Transitions between
gestures can be by sweeps so extensive, that any continuity
between gestures is lost. Such flourishes are meaningless.
"Fault 7" Too free a use of the
left hand. The right hand should be the principal gesture hand.
"Fault 8" Repeatedly raising the
hand or both hands suddenly, from the side, to effect a gesture,
then letting the hands drop to the sides. After a hand gesture
is performed, hands should remain where they are at the end of
the gesture.
"Fault 9" At all times, avoid
twitching and jerking gestures.
"Fault 10" ALL arm sweeps should be
outward from the shoulder, unless it is an inward arm sweep
ending with the hand on the forehead, eyes, breast, etc. or
into another gesture.
"Fault 11" Avoid partially concealing
the contenance by a gesture crossing the face.
Although much has been omitted, a sufficient amount
of information has been included so that
chironomia may now be explained. The book by
Barber states (p. 26) that "The most complicated
gestures are those which relate to the combined
positions and motions of arms and hands. These, however,
are expressed with sufficient accuracy in all their
movements by four or fewer symbolic leters for each
movement." As an example:
p h f d or s e q n
position of hand, elevation of arm, transverse situation
of the arm, force of the gesture, thus
p h f d means prone, horizontal,
forward, descending meaning:
Hand in prone position; arm at horizontal elevation;
the arm in the transverse forward direction; descending
(arriving at the final position, the arm descended from
a higher elevation).
s e q n means supine, elevated,
oblique, noting.
p h q – p d b describes
(by convention), first the right hand and right arm, the
second set after the dash representing the left hand and
left arm. In this example, right hand: prone, horizontal,
oblique; left hand: prone, downwards, backwards. Also by
convention, p h q – is the
right hand alone; – p d b
is the left hand alone. Head and eyes are marked with
upper-case letters, separated by hand and arm gestures
(countenance has priority over hand and arm gestures).
A line is used below head/eye hands/arms gestures, and
below this line are gestures for feet and steps. The
gestures for feet and steps are under the word (letters)
describing the head/eye or hands/arms gestures positioned
when the gestures are to take place. This chironomic language
of gestures, is placed above words sung or spoken.
Two examples appear below.
It has been pointed out that instruction books
about pantomime (chironomia)
were effectively not used in ballet d'action. The
reason for this is that chironomia required original,
creative gestures, and any "instruction book" was
inherently uncreative.
1
Another example of the gestures used in pantomime comes from one of
the early developers of ballet d'action, John Weaver. Rather than using
chironomia, a "vocabulary" of gestures
was compiled and used. 2
Here one can find gestures and actions of "... Hands, Fingers, Legs
and Feet, without making use of the tongue." and "... observing Mens
Natures, and assimilating their Manners, and imitating all things
with gesture; for Nature assign'd each Motion of the Mind its proper
Gesticulation and Countenance, as well as Tone ..."
Examples then follow of such gestures:
ADMIRATION
Raising up of the right Hand, Palm turn'd upwards, the Fingers
clos'd; and in one Motion the Wrist turn'd round and the Fingers
spread; the Body reclining, and Eyes fix'd on the Object.
ASTONISHMENT
Both Hands are thrown up towards the Skies; the Eyes also lifted
up, and the Body cast backwards.
JEALOUSY
Arms suspended, or a particular pointing the middle Finger to the
Eye; by an irresolute Movement throughout the Scene, and a
Thoughtfulness of Contenance.
UPBRAIDING
The Arms thrown forwards; the Palm of the Hands turn'd outward;
the Fingers open, and the Elbows turn'd inward to the Brest.
ANGER
The left Hand struck suddenly with the right, and sometimes
against the Brest.
THREATS
Raising the Hand, and shaking the bended Fist, knitting the
Brow, biting the Nails; and catching back the Breath.
POWER
The Arm, with impetuous Agitation, directed forwards to the
Person, with an awful Look.
IMPATIENCE
Smiting the Thigh, or Brest with the Hand.
INDIGNATION
Applying the Hand passionately to the Forehead; or by steping
back the right Foot, leaning the Body quite backward, the Arms
extended, Palms clos'd, and Hands thrown quite back; the Head
cast back, and the Eyes fix'd upwards.
COQUETRY
Affected Airs, given herself throughout the whole Dance.
NEGLECT
Scornful turning the Neck, the flirting outward the back of
the right Hand, with a Turn of the Wrist.
CONTEMPT
Scornful Smiles, forbidding Looks; tossing of the Head;
filliping of the Fingers, and avoiding the Object.
DISTASTE
The left Hand thrust forth with the Palm turn'd backward,
the left Shoulder rais'd, and the Head bearing towards the
Right.
DETESTATION
Both the turn'd-out Palms are so bent to the left Side,
and the Head still more projected from the Object ...
being a redoubled Action.
TRIUMPHING
Shake the Hand open, rais'd above our head, is an exulting
Expression.
ENTREATY
Stretching out the Hands downward toward the Knees.
GREIEF
Hanging down the Head; wringing the Hands; and striking the
Brest.
RESIGNATION
Hold out both the Hands joyn'd together.
FORGIVENESS
To extend and offer out the Right Hand.
SHAME
Covering the Face with the Hand.
RECONCILIATION
To shake the given Hand, or embrace the Body.
A similar but more extensive vocabulary of gestures used in
pantomime exists, but will not be discussed here.
3, 4
Rather, a very short discussion about a very important aspect
of pantomein. Specifically, the gestures used in pantomime
seem to fall into two distinct categories. Gestures used in
pantomime which might be viewed as "universal",
as opposed to the gestures of pantomime that are culture or time
dependent 4
(are NOT universal).
An indicative gesture of pantomime such as pointing with a finger
might be viewed as universal, as the finger is a convenient part
of the body that can be used to designate a source of sound, light
(image), odor, or even taste. However, nodding up and down with
the head to signify "yes" cannot be universal, as in some societies,
such a gesture signifies "no". Thus, if an art form such as ballet
d'action is to have a universal basis, it would seem to require
both classes of gesture, at the cost of not being transportable
without modification between different societies or at different
times if sufficiently remote.
We will now close our discussion of chironomia or a vocabulary of
gestures used in pantomime..
1
"Mime, Music and Drama on the Eighteenth-Century
Stage: The Ballet d'Action", Edward Nye, Cambridge
Univ. Press, 2011, pp. 135-138.
2
Weaver, John; "The loves of Mars and Venus; a dramatick entertainment
of dancing, attempted in imitation of the pantomimes of the ancient
Greeks and Romans; as perform'd at the theatre in Drury-Lane", 1717,
Eighteenth Century Collections Online, British Library, London
3
Barnett, Dene; with the assistance of Massey-Westropp, Jeanette;
"The Art of Gesture: The practices and principles of 18th century
acting", Carl Winter Universitätsverlag, Heidelberg, 1987
4
Jorio, Andrea de; "Gesture in Naples and Gesture in Classical
Antiquity", Kendon, Adam (translator), Indiana Univ. Press,
Bloomington, 2000 Especially, the following part of this book:
"The Plates and Explanations of the Plates", pp. 401-477 which
are more appropriate during the Renaissance and Baroque periods.